Sunday, October 2, 2011

Conversation about education with a friend from Berkeley


I haven't had time to post in a while, but I've been having some excellent conversations with friends about my experiences and what I have been learning here. I thought I'd post one in lieu of writing so i can make sure to keep you up to date.

 me:  sorry, transitioning from phone to computer
but yeah, essential
 Mohit:  no problem
 me:  lly
it all comes down to money
well and cultural valuation of education
especially education of poor, black children
 Sent at 4:29 PM on Sunday
 me:  it is definitely NOT because we have "bad" teachers
you have to be crazy to teach in an urban school and not care deeply about the well-being of children
otherwise you would leave
 Sent at 4:31 PM on Sunday
 Mohit:  yeah, that makes a lot of sense
 Sent at 4:33 PM on Sunday
 Mohit:  but
i'm trying to reconcile the two views
 Sent at 4:34 PM on Sunday
 Mohit:  i mean
obviously there are stories floating around of teachers doing nothing
and i understand that stories are just that
stories
but i've had unmotivated teachers in the past who do the minimal required
and i can't imagine they're the only ones
so
what gives?
(i'm intentionally playing devil's advocate to a certain extent.)
 Sent at 4:36 PM on Sunday
 me:  for one thing, as things are now, even the motivated teachers in KC can't do a good job because the administration is in flux because of the superintendent quitting
there's this huge reform push to change the whole system of education at at 10 KC elementary schools (mine being one of them) and we as teachers were hardly trained at all on how to work under the new system
like literally it was a week of optional training (that about a third of the teachers at my school attended) and 2 days of mandatory training
and the training was dismal at that
we teachers rely on our principals and our instructional coach, but they are only barely supported by the administration above

 Mohit:  wow
 me:  The district does almost nothing to provide opportunities for teachers to learn how to teach, but threatens everything they can when they feel teachers aren't doing their job
administrators only show up in our rooms or anywhere else to monitor
and in this case, it's to monitor for things that they are making us do, that are completely new this year, and they only spent 2 days trying to train us how to do
basically i think teachers should be paid more but also work an extra few weeks or a month on professional development every year
 Mohit:  yeah, that makes a lot of sense
i know that
when discussing the topic of teacher pay with people who are not berkeley students
the summer vacation gets mentioned a lot
it'd be interesting to repurpose that
 me:  yeah
i mean, i still think the per hour wage for teachers is too low
but, even you kept that constant and just added mandatory hours over the summer, it could be really effective
but that's a lot of money
that states don't have
 Sent at 4:46 PM on Sunday
 me:  also, our kids here need more help than we can give, so if we could have counselors and caseworkers and psychologists for every kid
everything would be a lot better
but they would have to be competent in the culture here
 Mohit:  it sounds to me like what's messed up is not the educational system, but the educational support system
 Sent at 4:49 PM on Sunday
 me:  well, i think they're one in the same, in theory
no, in practice too
 Mohit:  haha
 me:  but yeah, it is the support that is lacking, not the skill or dedication of the teachers
for the most part
there are some very bad teachers at my school
AND KC, unlike other places, has been able to purge some of its bad apples
 Sent at 4:51 PM on Sunday
 Mohit:  i guess that's both good and bad
good because there is quality
bad because we can't keep it good
anyway, i'm sure that you have to have this conversation every time you talk with somebody from berkeley
we'll continue it another time
tell me more about KC!

No comments:

Post a Comment